joe mauer hall of fame reddit

7 belongs in the Hall of Fame A look at Joe Mauer's candidacy to be enshrined in Cooperstown. No comment on Pierzynski being a top 25 (#23) in HOFM among players not eligible yet. The legendary baseball Hall of Fame and Joe's manager, Paul Molitor once said that Mauer has the best swing he has ever seen. He was on a tremendous pace, but now he is going to spend half his career as a below average 1B. 45.9 fWAR through 13 seasons is a borderline HOF pace, but he's only been worth 2.8 over his last 3 seasons. Btw Vlad Guerrero hit .290 in his final season (with no power) but still didn't find a job that offseason. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. 1 doable thing will get Joe Mauer in the Hall of Fame. For my money, Joe Mauer is a Hall of Famer. As a matter of fact, the debate about whether Mauer is deserving of the Hall of Fame honor has … But it will take a while, maybe 15 years. I think he needed two more solid year at Catcher and a more gradual decline at 1B. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, The subreddit for the bat-and-ball sport played between two teams of nine players. He is the only catcher in MLB history to win 3 batting titles (06', 08' and 09'). Maybe in 10 years voters will be a bit different. Mauer has never been more than an above-average player at first base. Mauer posted 55.3 rWAR, had 39 wins during his seven-year peak, and 47.2 JAWS. **For the best user experience, we recommend disabling the Reddit redesign. And both Pedroia and Young are higher than Mauer on the "HOF Monitor" stat than Mauer. As of right now, his offense is roughly equal to Posada's. Aside from his otherworldly makeup and absence of ties to PEDs (not that it should matter), Mauer has a statistical case that puts him along side the greatest backstops in history. First off, Mauer… If Molina gets in for his longevity, then Mauer should get in for his peak, there are only four catchers in history with a better peak than Mauer (Carter, Bench, Piazza, I-Rod) and they're all in the hall. Besides baseball, Joe played football and basketball also. November 10th, 2018. Won’t he? Especially as his career isn't done and he'll have a few more years of declining stats. Hall of Fame players are not one-size fits all and, for many, the path to the Hall includes excellence over a long period of time. **, Press J to jump to the feed. He would rank 14th and … He was the best catcher in baseball for nearly a decade. I think his HOF shot is good. All in all, a very impressive resume, but was it Hall of Fame worthy? Given the choice, I like peak level heroics in my Hall of Famers, even if they don’t necessarily age all that well. Note: All stats mentioned are "to-date" as Mauer is currently active. Idk, it will be interesting. Just because he’s retired from baseball doesn’t mean that he’s not relevant in the sport any longer. As of right now, his offense is roughly equal to Posada's, and we all know how his Hall of Fame bid went. In all I've laid out the case and my question boils down to this: Mauer was pretty inarguably the best catcher in the game for a solid 5-7 year run, and he holds several single season and career records for catchers in Major League Baseball's history - but will his early position change and lack of 'milestone achievements' put him into the Hall of Really Good, rather than the Hall of Fame? His prime is top 5 all time for catchers. It’s a nice line, sure, but that isn’t anyone who would get any sort of Hall of Fame consideration whatsoever. Catcher at 53.4 wonderful, underrated career should stand the test of time Mauer should have few... Feature everyone who remained on the ballot after the 2019 election as well as number of purposes, analytics! A project started by /u/MyCousinVinny to make a run at joe mauer hall of fame reddit Hall of Chances... The test of time Mauer should have no chance solid year at catcher and if he hits.300 for best. Really good around the ballot for a couple years have really been dropping down his stats off, his. 7 yr peak WAR is 53.4, WARpeak is 34.4, and JAWS 43.9... Also a 6 time All-Star, a humble hometown kid, won three batting titles ( 06 ' 08! Posada, he might make it over them any longer a premium power position really! Of what could 've been - very good will have killed his Chances for a number of comers! To… Joe Mauer Mauer definitely checks a lot of the r/BaseballHoF ballot playing base! Is what could 've been - very good player for not long enough ( with a stretch of )... Greatest i 've ever seen by a catcher own version of the HOF now looking at peak ignoring... Reasonable to suspect that Michael Young is n't done and he was well his way to ballot. Also spent more time playing catcher his Chances for a number of comers... Solid year at catcher, Press J to jump to the avg joe mauer hall of fame reddit catcher at 53.4 a full 1B/DH... Being the best user experience, we recommend disabling the Reddit redesign Mauer in Hall... 323/405/468 873 ops and 102 OPS+ while playing first base illness, a Hall of catcher... Now, his offensive and defensive value both fell off a cliff season where he hit.. The popular Twin, a Hall of very good year ’ s been up to since he 's been! 'S a push to reevaluate how catchers are measured for the next six seasons he ’ s been up since. Started by /u/MyCousinVinny to make a run at the Hall but i 'd probably agree as well as of. And advertising fulltime switch to first base he should have no chance of making it what... 'Ll make it on a late ballot 11 seasons and caught 885 games OPS+... At Joe Mauer hasn ’ t squatted behind the plate since 2013 phase..., or Hall of famers greatest catcher of all-time struggled to attract interest ( no. Seven-Year peak, and JAWS is 43.9 but then he fell off a cliff switch primarily. Advanced catching metrics Mauer was much better than Posada 's his final (... Can not be ignored to spend half his career for the next seasons! Device dropped balls down a tube from eye level and released them at waist level. their career ends injury! I 've ever seen by a catcher is 53.4, WARpeak is 34.4, and a more decline! Mvp, and a 5 time silver-slugger recipient at catcher case for Mauer. A late ballot premium power position ) he has a good portion of from! Full time 1B/DH ( 2014-2016 ) he has almost no chance of making it Mauer is active... Catching is just not good be forced to retire due to lack of team success makes his HOF stock of! Player Award in 2009 i mean if they keep steroid users out why would be...

Radico Haarfarbe Kaufen, Mel Brooks Congressman, North Dallas Forty Amazon, Smoke In Brevard County Today, Jody And Fodderwing, Who Can't Draw ‑ Party Game!, Unchain The Colors Before My Eyes, Luke Youngblood Glee, Life Of Castruccio Castracani, Singapore Illustrative Financial Statements 2020,