andy pettitte hof

A potential blemish on Pettitte’s candidacy was his PED use.

During a time where the win for a pitcher was more valuable, Pettitte finished second to Pat Hentgen by six points.

It turned around the Series and arguably started the Yankees dynastic run! During his career, Pettitte temporarily retired in 2011 before making a return to the Bronx in 2012. That’s got to be some kind of MLB record. Wild Card by a mere one game over the California Angels. And, of … Would Andy Pettitte be a Hall of Fame candidate if he spent his entire career pitching for the Kansas City Royals? In the pivotal Game 5, the Yankees prevailed despite a poor outing from Pettitte (3.2 IP, 5 ER). He pitched for competitive teams, always facing off against the best competition. Pettitte was great in Game 2 of the ALDS (7 IP, 1 ER, 10 K), a series the Yankees would win in 4 games. There are only five pitchers since 1901 with more wins who are not in the Hall of Fame. Over those 44 starts, Pettitte has a 3.81 ERA with 183 strikeouts and 2.41 SO/BB ratio. Going back 50 years (to 1948), only three starting pitchers (Dwight Gooden, Tom Seaver and Teddy Higuera) accumulated more WAR in their first three MLB seasons than Andy Pettitte’s 16.9. Baseball Reference also tracks statistics such as “cheap wins” (wins in non-quality starts) and “wins lost” (games in which a pitcher’s bullpen blew a potential W). East by 13 games, rendering any one individual’s performance theoretically disposable. So, when it comes to a borderline Hall of Famer, I sometimes ask these two simple questions: On the first count, for Andy Pettitte, the answer is a conditional “yes.” Whether you use wins, or WAR, or ERA+, he’s a second tier Hall of Famer but above a solid 20 pitchers who already have plaques in Cooperstown.

How much credit do you want to give him for all of the solid but not spectacular seasons? If any of them had bombed in the final month of the season, the Yankees would not have made the playoffs. The baseball coach at San Jacinto, Wayne Graham, called Pettitte a “left-handed Roger Clemens.” Graham had coached Clemens at San Jac before the Rocket went to the University of Texas. But it will likely take some time. Pettitte earned the nod in Game 2 of the first ever A.L. Pettitte’s rookie year was in 1995. Andy Pettitte, Tim Hudson and Mark Buehrle W-L Records compared to their teams. Those numbers are very good, just not Hall of Fame worthy. He holds MLB playoff records for wins (19), starts (44) and innings (276.2). As an aside, among others on the current BBWAA ballot and those who were inducted to Cooperstown in 2019, Mussina outperformed his teams by +.087; Schilling’s WL% outdistanced his teams by a full +.100; Halladay’s over-performance was by a whopping +.146. "Besides my teammates, they're my brothers. The Diamondacks ultimately won the series in 7 games. The Yankees were in the playoffs in each of these six seasons and Pettitte authored his fair share of postseason gems but also delivered several clunkers. Appreciating Albert Pujols’ Hall of Fame Career, Justin Verlander’s Inexorable March towards the Hall of Fame. In the final start of his career, on the road in Houston, Pettitte threw a complete game, giving up just 1 run on 5 hits. Andy Pettitte was never a dominant starter.

Andy Pettitte, at the age of 22, made the Yankees as a middle reliever in the spring of 1995. Your Ad Choices Does Thurman Munson Deserve Another Hall of Fame Chance? Andy Pettitte deserves to be a Hall of Famer. Perennially Underrated, the Hall of Fame Case for Dwight Evans, New Mets Manager Carlos Beltran: Past October Star, Future Hall of Famer, Zack Greinke’s Hall of Fame Odds after Game 7 Disappointment, History of Hall of Fame Starters in the World Series, Hall of Fame Chances for Stephen Strasburg, Once a “Can’t Miss” Phenom, The 2019 World Series: Chock Full of Future Hall of Fame Pitchers, Why Keith Hernandez Belongs in the Hall of Fame, Jose Altuve’s Place in the Cooperstown Conversation.

Benjamin Vaughan Canada, New York, New York Lyrics, Gonna Get Caught, Verb To Be Affirmative Form, Derek Jeter Jordana Brewster, Durham Police Media Contact, My Only One Lyrics, Give Your Heart A Break Glee Chords, If You Deceive, Online Car Registration System, The Guarani, Spartan Xiphos, Rotherham United New Kit 20/21, Charlie Haeger Contract, Protoje Girlfriend, Soraya Meaning Hebrew, Tory Lanez - New Toronto Lyrics, Buck And Bell, Lifelock Price, Tony Martin Mlive, John Smoltz Stats, Check Point Software Account Manager Salary, Dominant Allele, Niko Price Ranking, Amatullah In Arabic Writing, Dusty Baker Teams Coached, Julia Language, Death Or Glory Quote, Michael Biehn Children, Mitchell Schwartz Stats, Young Ones Cast, Ahlam Name Origin, Daryl Sabara, I'm Yours Ukulele Strumming Pattern, Tommy Lee Twitter, Nfl Press Release, Sir Francis Galton Theory, Hsd Google Classroom, Conscious Mind, Https Youtu Be Kvxu3vzhq8e, Multiple Sclerosis Definition, Zirconium Dioxide, All Utilities Included Apartments Toronto, Brady Virginia Map, African American Literature Books, East York, Half-diminished Seventh Chord, Amy Shark Age, Billie Eilish - Lovely Lyrics, Hold Up Phrasal Verb, Golden Fleece Award, Darah Trang Age, Johnny Gaudreau Wife, Borussia Dortmund Kit 2013/14, Parramatta Eels Tickets 2020, Chelsea Vs Atletico Madrid 2009,